I Tried 13 of the Most Popular Oreos, and the Best Flavor Totally Shocked Me

Oreo cookies had been launched in 1912. More than a century later, it is arduous to withstand grabbing a pack to twist and devour, smash right into a pie crust, or fold right into a home made ice cream batter. Beyond the OG taste, the model has launched all kinds of spinoffs, with some bordering on weird (i.e., Wasabi and Hot Chicken Wing) and others beloved, just like the now-discontinued Blueberry Pie and Fruity Crisp.

No matter which one you like, you will discover dozens of Oreo flavors to select from while you step right into a grocery retailer these days. Unless you comply with the model intently, chances are you’ll not sustain with new releases—which is the place I are available to assist. I gathered quite a lot of choices and spent almost a month sampling them to find out which cookies are price including to your cart, and which of them aren’t price your time.

After years of sticking to the OG Oreo taste and avoiding most limited-edition or new releases, I used to be stunned by the winner. Read on to see which one took the GOAT title.

How I Chose the Oreo Flavors

When it got here to selecting Oreo flavors, I visited main grocery shops and different retailers and scanned the cookie aisles to seek out as many types as potential. For this check, I selected to not pattern the gluten-free choices, since these could possibly be a class of their very own.

Navigating the world of Oreos might be complicated, with new flavors dropping incessantly and seasonal releases coming and going. For consistency, I caught to the varieties that had been out there through the week I shopped and averted any limited-edition releases that you simply’d solely discover on reseller websites like eBay. (As enjoyable as it will be to strive a pack of Cherry Blossom Matcha Oreos worth $1000it simply wasn’t within the funds.)

How I Tested the Oreo Flavors

The greatest Oreo cookies embody three key parts that make up a scrumptious sandwich cookie. For starters, the biscuit must be subtly candy, with a pleasant crumbly texture while you chew into it. As for the style, the filling ought to have a pronounced taste that is not overly candy. Lastly, a very nice Oreo must be so satisfying that, when you style it, you are tempted to snack on a complete row.

With these qualities in thoughts, I got down to strive the completely different sorts of Oreos out there. To hold the exams balanced, I restricted myself to tasting solely three flavors per day. Between rounds, I cleansed my palate with seltzer water to scrub away any fats from the cream filling and lingering richness of the cookie. Below, you will discover my subjective listing of Oreo flavors ranked from least favourite to the one undoubtedly price your time.

The Best Oreo Flavors Puffs, Ranked

thirteenth Place: Oreo Java Chip Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

As quickly as I opened the pack of Java Chip Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, an amazing espresso aroma crammed the room. The first chew hit me with a robust latte-like taste that tasted disagreeable, synthetic, and overly candy. The icing additionally had a waxy texture that was arduous to disregard.

twelfth Place: Oreo Toffee Crunch Creme with Sugar Crystals Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

Toffee cookies are a few of my favorites, however this Oreo model turned out to be an excessively candy mess. The toffee bits folded into the caramel-colored icing added a pleasant crunch, which I appreciated, however that added texture wasn’t sufficient to miss the flavour. The sandwich cookie left a medicinally candy aftertaste that was arduous to disregard.

eleventh Place: Oreo Lemon Creme Sandwich Cookies

I often love citrus-flavored desserts, however this one utterly missed the mark. The lemon taste was too daring and robust, and tasted extra synthetic than scrumptious. In reality, the cookie was the one edible a part of the deal with as a result of the filling was disagreeable and overpowering.

tenth Place: Oreo Original Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

For years, I’ve reached for the OG Oreo taste, however after making an attempt over a dozen varieties, I noticed the common one is only a tad bit boring. Don’t get me fallacious, it stays scrumptious and a GOAT in its personal proper, and I plan to maintain utilizing it in pie crusts and different baking tasks. But, as a snack by itself, the choices beneath provide far more pleasure.

ninth Place: Oreo Birthday Cake Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

I did not anticipate a lot from the Birthday Cake-flavored cookie, since this taste typically leans cloyingly candy. But after taking a chew, as a substitute of tasting an amazing observe of sugar, I discovered that the confetti sprinkles added depth to the plain icing. Though it did not measure as much as the highest contenders, it nonetheless presents a enjoyable expertise for anybody who enjoys twisting open sandwich cookies full of rainbow hues.

eighth Place: Oreo Loaded Sandwich Cookies

This extra-stuffed model depends on the traditional chocolate cookies and fills them with an overabundance of Oreo-flavored icing. The style impressed me, and its mild, ethereal texture resembled desserts with fluffy frosting piped into it. However, after a couple of bites, the filling left a waxy aftertaste that took away from the expertise.

seventh Place: Oreo Mint Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

Biting into this taste introduced again reminiscences of savoring a field of Thin Mints from the Girl Scouts. The cool mint enhances the cookie’s chocolate notes. While the filling errs on the candy facet, the general taste is properly balanced, because of the richness of the chocolate. Like the profitable decide, this one would really shine with a fudge coating, remodeling it right into a standout, decadent deal with.

sixth Place: Oreo Chocolate Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

This chocolate Oreo presents a taste profile just like the darkish chocolate model, however with a milkier style. While the cocoa notes may gain advantage from coming by way of extra strongly, I did discover that the filling is extra balanced than the normal sugary white icing discovered within the OG Oreos.

fifth Place: Oreo Golden Sandwich Cookies

The Golden Oreo cookie is spectacular sufficient to earn a spot that is excessive up within the ranks. Its buttery base and refined vanilla notes create an irresistible chew. It tastes like a extra delicate, thinner model of a shortbread biscuit. While the filling is fairly candy, the cookie’s butteriness brings a pleasant steadiness to the general taste.

4th Place: Oreo Double Stuf Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

I need to confess: I did not take pleasure in Double Stuf Oreos the primary time I attempted them years in the past. But this time round, the creamy, velvety filling pleasantly stunned me. Each time I bit into the crunchy chocolate cookie, a mound of candy icing spilled out of the edges, which I appreciated.

third Place: Oreo Thins Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

For years, I averted Oreo Thins at any time when I noticed them on retailer cabinets, so my expectations had been low for this feature. But after taking a chew and feeling it soften in my mouth like a wafer cookie, my thoughts shortly modified. The texture delivers a crisp, mild really feel, just like treats from Tate’s model. Resisting the urge to eat a complete row of those chocolatey sandwich cookies in a single sitting was almost inconceivable.

2nd Place: Oreo Dark Chocolate Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

I admire store-bought cookies that ship depth in taste, and these darkish chocolate Oreos achieved precisely that. Each chew provided a pleasant richness that introduced out the cocoa, and in contrast to a few of the different OG fillings, this recipe managed to realize a creamy, ganache-like style fairly than a flat, sugary icing.

1st Place Winner: Oreo Fudge Covered Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

I do not know why I have never been placing this fudge-covered rendition in my cart all of those years, particularly since they’re priced at almost the identical value as a conventional pack of Oreos. The fudge-covered cookies are decadent and style like the kind of dessert you’d discover in a chocolate store.

Despite these Oreos being dunked in fudge, their taste is properly balanced—the coating does not overpower the style of the cookie. In distinction, the fudge provides a easy layer to chew into earlier than reaching that iconic, crumbly biscuit. The filling offers a distinct sugary shock that helps marry the entire flavors and textures collectively.

This is certainly the fanciest Oreo, but when you are going to purchase a pre-made candy snack, why not seize one which tastes prefer it was made by knowledgeable pastry chef?