15 Potluck Dessert Recipes That’ll Make You Famous At Church

Choco-Coconut Bar Cookies

“This coconut bar cookie recipe was passed down from my maternal Gramie Watson, and quickly became a crowd favorite. It’s one of the most requested treats at my kids’ schools, church gatherings, and any other occasion where it’s shared.” —debbthebee

Chocolate Trifle

“This chocolate trifle has layers of brownies, chocolate pudding, and whipped topping. It’s so easy to make and delicious! Folks line up for this dessert at church functions.” —Wayne

Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake

“This moist and buttery coffee cake has a generous cinnamon streusel topping for the perfect combination of taste and texture. Great for brunch, potlucks, or picnics.” —Nicole McLaughlin

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

“I was served white chocolate macadamia nut cookies at a restaurant in Springfield, MO, during a business conference. Went home and made up this recipe which has been a hit at any church gathering I take them to. They’re even better than the one I had at the conference.” —Mary

Sweet Potato Dump Cake

“This easy sweet potato dump cake is like sweet potato casserole, the dessert version. Buttery and sweet, with a crunchy top, you’ll be the hit of every fall potluck you’re invited to.” —Kathryn Hendrix

Yia Yia’s Baklava

“This recipe was passed from my Yia Yia to her daughter-in-law (my mother) to me. People love this as a Christmas gift. It has gained a big reputation among our friends. One time, my mother donated a small tin of baklava to a church charity auction. It was very competitive, but the price was driven up to $40!” —Jacolyn

Apple Cobbler

“This apple cobbler is a delicious, easy dish to take to your next potluck! Use your favorite apples or pie filling.” —Erica Thomas Cox

Glazed Cheese Danish Squares

“These glazed Danish squares are super quick and easy, great for potlucks. Best kept in fridge and served cold.” —Therese Aronica

Chocolate-Dipped Coconut Macaroons

“Even first-time cookie makers can pull off super moist, tender, chewy macaroons. Using sweetened condensed milk streamlines the operation and produces a very nice texture. Simple to make and easy to transport, these are the ultimate cookies to bring to any potluck. Just stick an almond inside each macaroon if you want to relive that chocolate-coated coconut-filled candy bar of your childhood.” —Chef John

Mrs. Sigg’s Snickerdoodles

“Try this snickerdoodle recipe for soft and chewy cinnamon-sugar cookies that everyone will enjoy. With crispy edges, chewy centers, and a deliciously spiced sugar coating, these cookies are a crowd please for sure. These snickerdoodle cookies have become very popular with my friends at church—and my pastor loves them. You will too!” —Beth Sigworth

Triple Berry Cheesecake Poke Cake

“For this triple-berry cheesecake poke cake recipe, poke a classic yellow cake and fill it with homemade berry sauce before topping it with a tangy, delicious, no-bake cheesecake filling! This cake is best made the day before and is great for all those summer potlucks!” —Julie Hubert

Best Bake Sale Banana Muffins

“These delectable banana muffins are the best ones you will ever taste. They have become a household favorite and an item I bake for every bake sale, potluck, and social gathering. Enjoy with your family and friends for years to come.” —Aoife Kenny

Peanut Butter Fudge with Condensed Milk

“Made with just three ingredients, this peanut butter fudge with condensed milk is a quick and easy dessert option for parties or potlucks.” —ROCKYSMOM

Sopapilla Cheesecake Pie

“This sopapilla cheesecake is easy to make, smells great while cooking, and tastes wonderful! I take this to potluck dinners, and it always gets rave reviews.” —CandelB

Pumpkin Cake

“This recipe for a delicious pumpkin cake is baked in a sheet pan. It’s lightly spiced, very moist, and great for potlucks. When cool, top with your favorite cream cheese frosting.” —SUE CASE

More Inspiration